The United States economy seems to be at an inflection point in which growth will either accelerate above the trend or remain below. The March Employment report had some very positive signs, which showed that more people are finding jobs. According to the Wall Street Journal, “All of the gains came from private companies, which added 192,000 jobs. The March gain means the private sector has regained all the positions lost in the recession”. Although the 192,000 jobs added was just below forecasts, I think it is a strong number that proves the December and January employment reports were outliers that were negatively impacted by severe winter weather. The recovery has been painfully slow in the labor market, but the March employment report was a significant step in the right direction. The better level of hiring, as evidenced by the March employment report, will hopefully give a boost to consumer confidence and in turn support consumption expenditures.
According to Ray Dalio, credit expansion and credit contraction essentially determine booms and busts in economic business cycles. Following many years of expansion, the credit market collapsed in the recent financial crisis. Thus, the health of private credit markets is central to the current inflection point of the U.S. economy.
As seen above, the year over year percent change in private credit has recently turned in the right direction. If credit markets continue to strengthen, households will be able to take on more leverage. An improvement in private credit conditions is indispensable to supporting the positive signs in the March employment report.
If the March employment report was so lovely and credit conditions are improving, then why the recent dip in financial markets? I believe changing expectations about future interest rates played a significant role. Expectations about interest rate increases are mid-2015 (i.e. 6 months following the end of quantitative easing) and there are concerns surrounding what the impact will be on each sector of the U.S. economy. On the one hand, financial stocks moved up on the news as they stand to earn more interest revenue from loans. On the other hand, sectors sensitive to interest rates (ex. Housing) will likely suffer when rates move up at first. For example, higher interest rates decrease affordability in the housing market and could potentially lead to decreased residential investment. A key rate to watch is the ten-year Treasury yield, which is usually considered the risk-free rate for long-term debt and is thus intertwined with many other rates.
The yield on the ten-year Treasury has tested 3%, but has remained below it. I believe it is only a matter of time before the 3% level is breached. As mid-2015 approaches, expectations about future rates will need to be fully priced in. As a result, a first test for the inflection point will be whether sectors that are sensitive to interest rates can handle higher rates. If all of this goes smoothly, then the United States economy could reach escape velocity and grow above the cyclical trend of 2.5%. Wonderful! Not so fast… According to the Wall Street Journal,
If the U.S. grows a half-percentage point faster than expected, it would force the Federal Reserve to raise interest rates at a quicker clip. That would boost borrowing costs for emerging markets more than many governments and investors planned, raising serious questions about the ability of countries, households and corporations to pay off their debts.
Although I am hoping for stronger economic growth in the United States, I was unaware that it might cause problems for the rest of the world. To be clear, the IMF is expecting the U.S. economy to expand at 2.8% this year and 3% in 2015. I am not sure how likely the U.S. is to grow above these levels, but I am very pleased by the signs in the labor and credit markets. Hypothetically, if U.S. economic growth takes off, then the Fed must respond quickly and effectively with higher rates despite a negative impact on the rest of the world. As the Fed demonstrated during the major sell off in emerging markets this year, the Fed’s mandate is the U.S. economy and so it must keep its focus here.